|Space Launch Report: SpaceX Falcon 9 Data Sheet|
|Home On the Pad Space Logs Library Links|
Updated May 01, 2017
Falcon 9 v1.1 Data Sheet (New April 29, 2013)
Dot-com multimillionaire Elon Musk established SpaceX Corporation in June 2002 in an El Segundo, California warehouse, intent on developing the small "Falcon" launch vehicle and the rocket engines to power it. By early 2003, the company was testing early prototypes of its 40-tonne-thrust-class Merlin first stage engine and 3.17 tonne thrust Kestrel second stage engine at its McGregor, Texas test site.
Merlin was a gas generator cycle engine that used a pintle style injector, an injector design adapted from the Apollo Lunar Module engine. Turbopump exhaust provided roll control. The engine had an ablatively cooled thrust chamber and nozzle.
Kestrel, which also used a pintle injector, was a
pressure fed design. Kestrel had a radiatively cooled Niobium nozzle and an
ablatively cooled chamber and throat.
Enter Falcon 5
On December 3, 2003 in Washington D.C., during its Falcon "protovehicle" unveiling ceremonies, Elon Musk announced that SpaceX planned to follow-up Falcon (thereafter called "Falcon 1") with a more powerful 3.7 meter diameter launch vehicle named "Falcon 5" that would be capable of hauling 4.2 tonnes to low earth orbit (LEO) and 1.25 tonnes to geosynchronous transfer orbit (GTO). Falcon 5 launches would be priced at $12 million.
Falcon 5 would stand about 29 meters tall and weigh
about 130 tonnes at liftoff. Its first stage would be powered by five Merlin engines
producing a total of 162.13 tonnes of thrust at liftoff and 192 tonnes in vacuum.
Two upgraded Kestrel engines would boost the second stage, producing nearly 6.8 tonnes of
total thrust. Like Falcon 1, Falcon 5 would usa a "pressure assisted
stabilized" graduated monocoque friction stir-welded aluminum design with a common
bulkhead between its aft kerosene tank and its forward liquid oxygen tank. Both
stages would be helium pressurized and would be designed to be recovered at sea after
floating down beneath parachutes. SpaceX hoped to recover parts of the stages
At the ceremony, Elon described goals that seem hopelessly optimistic in retrospect. He expected to fly the first Falcon 5 in November 2005 and to launch six Falcon 1 and four to six Falcon 5 missions per year by 2010 from still-to-be-developed launch sites at Cape Canaveral, Vandenberg, and Omelek Island at Kwajalein Atoll in the Marshall Islands.
Development realities intervened during 2004, when
SpaceX struggled with Merlin development. Cast aluminum manifolds cracked during
tests, requiring replacement with heavier inconel manifolds. The engines were not
quite as efficient as planned, requiring thrust to be increased to offset the lower
specific impulse. Merlin had to be redesigned and retested, a process that extended
through the year.
During 2005, SpaceX began Falcon 5 fabrication and development. Plans called for 12 Merlin 1B engines to be completed during the year, but in September 2005, the plans changed. SpaceX announced that it would develop "Falcon 9", powered by nine Merlin 1B first stage engines, to meet the needs of an unnamed government customer. Falcon 9 would be able to boost more than 9 tonnes to LEO or more than 3 tonnes to geosynchronous transfer orbit (GTO) for $27 million. Even more powerful versions, with parallel Falcon booster strap-ons, were projected for the future. Falcon 9S5 would use two Falcon 5 strap-on boosters. Falcon 9S9 would use two Falcon 9 strap-on boosters. No longer a Delta II class launch vehicle, Falcon 9 entered the EELV payload category.
The Falcon 5 design was changed yet again, becoming a partially loaded Falcon 9 stripped down to only 5 Merlin first stage engines. The change meant that Falcon 5's LEO payload fell to 4 tonnes while its price rose to $18 million.
The first Falcon 1 launch campaign at Omelek extended through the final months of 2005 into the early months of 2006, culminating with an inaugural flight failure on March 24, 2006. SpaceX spent much of 2006 evaluating, and recovering from, the failure.
Dragon, NASA COTS, and Merlin 1C
In September, 2006, SpaceX won one of two NASA Commercial Orbital Transportation Services contracts. The $278 million award was for three flight demonstrations by SpaceX of its to-be-developed 7 tonne "Dragon" spacecraft on Falcon 9 launch vehicles. The launches, planned at the time to begin in late 2008, would demonstrate Dragon's ability to haul 3.1 tonnes of cargo to the International Space Station (ISS) and to return cargo to Earth.
During 2006, Elon Musk also announced that SpaceX had decided to begin work on a "Merlin 1C" engine with a regeneratively cooled thrust chamber. In early February 2007, SpaceX updated its web site with revised design information for both Merlin and Falcon. The data was said to be effective for vehicles launched in 2009 or later. Merlin 1C was shown to produce 46.259 tonnes of sea-level thrust - a 32% increase over the thrust produced by Merlin during the initial Falcon 1 launches. Falcon 9 was shown using nine Merlin 1C engines, providing a 20% thrust increase over the previously announced Merlin 1B engines.
By the time a revised Payload User's Guide was published in May 2007, Falcon 5 had disappeared from the company's catalog altogether. Falcon 9 and Falcon 9S9 (now called Falcon 9 Heavy) payloads had grown by more than 10% from earlier specifications.
The second Falcon 1 failed on March 21, 2007, a victim of second stage propellant sloshing that caused loss of flight control about 5 minutes after liftoff. While the company labored to learn more lessons from its little Falcon, it forged ahead with Falcon 9 development and fabrication.
Cape Canaveral Launch Site Selection
In April 2007, SpaceX signed an agreement to lease Cape Canaveral Space Launch Complex 40, a mothballed Titan IV pad, for five years for Falcon 9 launches. The original agreement included use of the ex-Titan IVB SMARF high bay for Falcon 9 integration, but the company subsequently decided to build a smaller horizontal integration hanger near the launch pad itself. The Titan IV umbilical tower was removed as a first step. On April 27, 2008, the massive Titan IV mobile service tower, once called the world's largest moving object, was taken down with demolition charges. SpaceX planned to use the Titan IV exhaust duct, lightning towers, and other structures, but Falcon 9 processing would use a "clean" pad without use of a large mobile tower.
Meanwhile, in October 2007, SpaceX moved from El Segundo to a larger (51,000 square meter) facility in Hawthorne, California. Vought Aircraft had formerly used the site to fabricate 747 fuselages for Boeing. SpaceX planned to employ 400 at the site, along with 50 in Texas and elsewhere.
Falcon 9 Testing Begins
On November 12, 2007, SpaceX announced that it had completed Merlin 1C engine development with a 170 second hot fire test at its Texas Test Facility near McGregor, Texas. The development engine test program included 125 hot fire tests totaling more than 3,000 seconds duration. This first Merlin 1C could produce 43 tonnes of thrust at sea level and 49 tonnes in vacuum.
SpaceX shipped its first Falcon 9 first stage to McGregor in mid-2007. The stage was erected into the company's massive Big Falcon Test Stand during August. During November, 2007 the first Falcon 9 hot fire test, using only one Merlin 1C engine, was performed. This was followed by a two engine test in January 2008 and a three-engine test in early March, 2008. Five engine testing occurred in late May, 2008. The first nine engine test was performed on June 31, 2008, in a test that produced 385.5 tonnes of total thrust. Two more less-than-full-duration 9-engine tests followed.
On November 23, 2008, SpaceX performed the first full-duration nine-engine Falcon 9 test at McGregor. Producing 387.8 tonnes of total thrust while burning nearly 227 tonnes of propellant, the burn lasted 178 seconds. Two of the nine Merlin 1C engines shut down as planned after 160 seconds, a sequence that mimicked the planned flight shutdown method. The late-evening test startled Central Texas residents more than 20 miles away.
Testing at McGregor used a battleship-type "run tank". After the full duration test, SpaceX planned to remove the "run tank" and send its engines to Cape Canaveral, where the first Falcon 9 flight stage was expected to arrive by the end of 2008. That flight stage was expected to be used for facility testing at SLC 40, culminating in a static test firing in early 2009. Another flight stage was expected to arrive at McGregor for formal qualification testing. One of these stages would presumably perform the inaugural Falcon 9 launch sometime in 2009.
New Falcon Details Emerge
In April 2008, SpaceX revealed new details for the higher-thrust Merlin 1C that would power both Falcon 1e and a "Block 2" version of Falcon 9 that would fly in 2010 or later. The upgraded Merlin 1C would produce 56.69 tonnes of sea-level thrust and 63.45 tonnes of thrust in vacuum, 1.5-1.6 times more than the original Merlin. With more available liftoff thrust, Falcon 1e and Falcon 9, Block 2 both grew substantially heavier and more capable.
The Block 2 Falcon 9 would be able to lift nearly 10.5 tonnes to LEO from Cape Canaveral and 4.54 tonnes to a 28.5 deg GTO. Stage recovery attempts were planned when lighter payloads were launched, with unused payload mass apparently assigned to recovery hardware. Block 1 Falcon 9, powered by the initial lower-thrust Merlin 1C engines, would perform the early COTS Demonstration flights.
On December 23, 2008, SpaceX won a $1.6 billion Commercial Resupply Services (CRS) contract to haul NASA cargo to the International Space Station. The contract covered 12 missions planned to fly between 2010 and 2016. SpaceX would use its Dragon spacecraft to perform the missions.
Cape Canaveral Validation
During the final days of 2008, SpaceX shipped its first Falcon 9 to Cape Canaveral SLC 40, along with the Falcon 9 launch stand and launch vehicle erector. The launch vehicle, which SpaceX said included some flight components, was shipped in pieces on a series of trucks from Hawthorne, California. The propulsion section used for the November 23, 2008 full-duration "run tank" test in Texas was also trucked to Florida, with all nine Merlin 1C engines installed, and attached to the Falcon 9 first stage. The entire vehicle, with a satellite payload fairing, was assembled near the launch pad, in the open, using rented cranes, by the end of the year. The launch mount and erector were also assembled. The SLC 40 Falcon 9 hanger had not yet been completed. Initial efforts appeared to be focused on mechanical fit-checks.
Merlin Vacuum Certification
On March 7, 2009, SpaceX performed a full mission duration firing of the new Merlin Vacuum engine at McGregor. The engine fired for six minutes, consumed 45.36 tonnes of propellant, and demonstrated a vacuum specific impulse of 342 seconds, highest ever for a U.S. hydrocarbon rocket engine. The engine produced 41.96 tonnes of thrust in vacuum conditions.
The Merlin Vacuum engine is based on the Merlin 1C, but
is fitted with a larger exhaust nozzle and an added radiatively cooled expansion nozzle
attachment. It has demonstrated throttling down to 75%, with plans to test down to
First Flight Vehicle Acceptance Testing
During 2009 and early 2010, the first Falcon 9 flight vehicle stages were acceptance tested at McGregor. Structural acceptance testing of both stages was completed by October 5, 2009. The first stage was test fired for 10 seconds on October 12 and for 30 seconds on October 16, completing its testing program. The stage was shipped to Cape Canaveral during November, 2009.
The second stage was test fired in a second, smaller
McGregor test stand for 40 seconds during November. On January 2, 2010, the Falcon 9
second stage completed a full duration mission firing, its Merlin Vacuum engine producing
41.96 tonnes of thrust for 329 seconds. The stage was shipped to the Cape, where it
arrived on January 29, 2010. There, it joined the first stage in the new SpaceX SLC
40 horizontal integration hanger.
SpaceX assembled its first flight Falcon 9 at Cape Canaveral SLC 40 during February, 2010. The rocket was powered up and put through an integrated systems test before being rolled out to its pad on February 20. On February 26, the rocket was loaded with propellant during its first wet dress rehersal countdown.
The rocket performed a 3.5 second "hot fire"
static test on March 13, 2010, during which the nine Merlin 1C first stage engines ignited
and ramped up to full thrust. The successful test took place four days after the
initial attempt had been scrubbed only two seconds before ignition. The scrubbed
test identified a problem with the launch sequencer, which failed to issue a command to
open a ground helium valve.
The first SpaceX Falcon 9 two-stage kerosene rocket launched from Cape Canaveral on June 4, 2010. Liftoff from Space Launch Complex 40 occurred at 18:45 UTC. The rocket carried a Dragon spacecraft simulator toward a planned 250 km x 34.4 deg low earth orbit.
Falcon 9's nine Merlin first stage engines developed 387.825 tonnes of liftoff thrust to slowly lift the 320-333 tonne, 47 meter tall rocket off its launch platform. The rocket rolled slightly immediately after liftoff, but steadied itself as it cleared the pad. Falcon 9 then flew smoothly through its initial ascent and pitch profile as it projected a thunderous roar back down onto observers at the Cape and Kennedy Space Center.
The center two Merlin engines shut down as planned about
165 seconds into the flight. The remaining first stage engines cut off at about 181
SpaceX claimed that the stage and payload had reached orbital parameters very close to the planned orbit, but initial U.S. orbital tracking data showed a less precise, 235 x 276 km x 34.5 deg orbit. Subsequent tracking showed the stage in a 242 x 269 km x 34.5 deg orbit.
During a teleconference after the launch, Elon Musk of SpaceX stated that the second stage Merlin Vacuum engine had performed a brief "burp" restart during its first orbit as an engineering test, but provided no details of the burn. Later reports suggested that an attempted restart had failed shortly before the stage passed over Australia.
Observers in eastern Australia saw the stage pass overhead about 65 minutes after liftoff. Video of the pass showed that the stage was still rolling out of control, venting gas to form a spiral pattern. The observations raised questions about whether the second stage on-board cold-gas three-axis control system had either failed or if an operational system was even flown during this test.
The stage and its attached Dragon simulator were tracked until they reentered the Earth's atmosphere on June 27, 2010.
Falcon 9 No. 1 produced more thrust at liftoff than any U.S.-powered kerosene-fueled rocket since Saturn IB SA-210 carried the Apollo Soyuz Test Project spacecraft with three crew into orbit on July 17, 1975. Merlin Vacuum performed the first U.S. turbopump-fed kerosene engine air-start since the last Titan I ICBM flew in 1965.
Falcon 9 Orbits Dragon C1
The second SpaceX Falcon 9 successfully boosted the company's Dragon C1 spacecraft into orbit from Cape Canaveral on December 8, 2010. The two-stage, 313 tonne, kerosene/LOX rocket thundered aloft off from Space Launch Complex 40 at 15:43 UTC. After a nearly nine-minute propulsion phase and a 20 second coast, Dragon C1 separated from Falcon 9's second stage, leaving its aft "trunk" section attached to the stage on this test flight, into a reported 288 x 301 km x 34.53 deg orbit, beginning a test flight planned for at least two orbits.
Dragon subsequently completed two orbits, demonstrating active flight control through use of its 18 Draco thrusters. According to some reports, one Draco failed to function, but redundancy in the flight control system design allowed the flight to continue. Elon Musk himself said after the flight that all thrusters worked. After two orbits, Dragon fired four Dracos beginning at about 18:17 UTC to initiate reentry. The capsule reentered over the Pacific Ocean and splashed down at about 19:02 UTC beneath three parachutes about 800 km off the northwest coast of Mexico.
Dragon C1 was the first SpaceX flight for NASA's Commercial Orbital Transportation Services (COTS) contract. It was the first spacecraft successfully launched and recovered from orbit by a commercial company. Only countries - the United States, Russia, China, Japan, India, and the European Space Agency - have previously performed the feat.
After Dragon deployed, several "CubeSat" microsatellites were released into low Earth orbit, likely from the Dragon trunk section that remained attached to the top of the orbiting Falcon 9 second stage on this test mission. One flew for the Naval Research Laboratory. Another, the first U.S. Army built satellite in more than 50 years, was identified as the Space and Missile Defense Command - Operational Nanosatellite Effect, or SMDC-ONE.
After the flight, CEO and Chief Engineer
Elon Musk announced that the second stage Merlin Vacuum engine had successfully restarted
in a test, propelling the stage to a 288 x 11,083 km x 34.6 deg elliptical orbit.
The first stage was not recovered, but telemetry of the stage reentry was recovered
through use of a data pod.
Merlin 1D, Falcon Heavy, and the future of Falcon 9
Falcon Heavy as Originally Presented by SpaceX, April 2011
On April 5, 2011, SpaceX announced that it would develop a triple-body Falcon Heavy powered by an upgraded engine named Merlin 1D. Each of the rocket's 27 Merlin 1D engines would produce 63.5 tonnes thrust at sea level, nearly 1.5 times more than the Merlin 1C engines that powered the first two Falcon 9 rockets. Using the new engines, combined with propellant crossfeeding from the twin boosters to the central core, Falcon Heavy would be able to lift a surprising 53 tonnes to LEO, 19 tonnes to GTO, or 13.6 tonnes toward Mars. Plans called for the first Falcon Heavy to fly a demonstration mission in 2013 from Vandenberg AFB Space Launch Complex 4 East, the former Titan 4 pad.
SpaceX also divulged plans for a two-stage Falcon 9 powered by nine Merlin 1D engines. This Falcon 9, substantially more capable than either Falcon 9 Block 1 or Block 2, would be able to lift 16 tonnes to LEO or 5 tonnes to GTO, would stand 69.2 meters, and would weigh 480 tonnes at liftoff. The company continued to show Falcon 9 Block 2 as the baseline in its Payload Users Guide.
On April 25, 2011, Elon Musk, in a Space News interview, confirmed that Falcon Heavy would use a "stretched" Falcon 9 stage augmented by two additional "first stages". He stated that Merlin 1D would fly in mid-2012 on a Falcon 9 mission, most likely on the seventh flight of the rocket. Mr. Musk described how the Merlin 1D combustion chamber is being explosively formed, streamlining the production process. He noted that a fully integrated Merlin 1D was already being test-fired.
During the August 2011 Joint Propulsion Conference, SpaceX VP of Propulsion Tom Mueller said that the Merlin 1D test engine had demonstrated a thrust to weight ratio greater than 160:1 and a vacuum specific impulse greater than 309 seconds.
Design details of Falcon Heavy, and of Merlin 1D
performance, have not been divulged. In order to achieve the payload capability
claimed by SpaceX, the new rocket engine will have to provide improved specific impulse
and the stages will have to provide very high propellant mass ratios. SpaceX claimed
that the two "first stage" strap-on units will achieve a 30 to 1 gross mass to
dry mass ratio, implying an unprecedented propellant mass fraction of better than 0.966.
On May 14, 2012, NASA announced that it had modified its Launch Services (NLS) II contract with Space Exploration Technologies (SpaceX) by adding a new "Falcon 9 v1.1" variant to the program. The modification allowed SpaceX to offer "Falcon 9 v1.1" in competition for future launch contracts.
An image of "Falcon 9 v1.1" was provided during a presentation made on March 9, 2012 by Jeffrey White, an Iridium Director. The image showed a stretched Falcon 9, with both stages stretched. It also showed, compared to Falcon 9 Block 1, shortened interstage and propulsion sections. The bigger rocket appeared to be outfitted with Merlin 1D engines, possibly in a rearranged configuration.
By appearances, "Falcon 9 v1.1" represents an improvement over the long-expected "Falcon 9 Block 2" that, originally, was to be powered by improved Merlin 1C engines. The SpaceX user's guide continued to show outmoded "Block 2" performance data as of May 14, 2012, but the SpaceX web site was updated with v1.1 performance number on June 6 or 7, 2011.
The Merlin 1D powered "Falcon 9 v1.1" is
likely the building block for the company's announced Falcon Heavy, but "v1.1"
should also be a substantial performer in its own right, pushing deep into EELV payload
territory. Falcon 9 v1.1 will likely premier at Vandenberg AFB Space Launch Complex 4 East during 2013.
During a May 18, 2012 interview, Elon Musk said that all Falcon 9 rockets after the first
five would be 1.1 versions. He also referred to the original Falcon 9 as
"v1.0". An extension of the Cape Canaveral SLC 40 Hanger was underway
during May, 2012 to accomodate the longer rocket.
Falcon 9 Orbits Dragon on COTS C2+ Mission
Merlin 1C Engines Undergoing Chilldown During Final Minutes of Countdown
The third SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket successfully orbited the company's first fully functional Dragon spacecraft on the COTS C2+ Demonstration Mission for NASA on May 22, 2012. The two stage, kerosene fueled rocket lifted off from Cape Canaveral Space Launch Complex 40 at 07:44 UTC, beginning an ambitious mission that, if fully implemented, would see the spacecraft docked to the International Space Station for two weeks.
It was Falcon 9's first night launch. The liftoff ended a 17 month hiatus for the launch vehicle as SpaceX worked to prepare Dragon for the C2+ mission.
Falcon 9 No. 3 Liftoff
Falcon 9's first stage burned for three minutes, its second stage for an additional 6 minutes 14 seconds, to inject Dragon into a 297 x 346 km x 51.6 deg phasing orbit. Dragon's twin solar arrays, on their inaugural flight, deployed shortly after spacecraft separation. The arrays were attached to Dragon's "trunk", an aft module attached to the cone shape spacecraft that was also on its first fully configured flight.
The launch occurred three days after a last second
launch abort that was caused by a faulty helium purge check valve on the launcher's center
Merlin 1C engine. Crews identified the problem and replaced the valve while Falcon 9
remained vertical on the pad.
Dragon carried 460 kg of demonstration cargo for ISS.
Plans call for it to return 620 kg of cargo when it reenters and splashes down in
the Pacific Ocean. But the ISS docking is contingent on Dragon successfully
completing a series of demonstration maneuvers for NASA during the first two days of its
mission, before it will be allowed to approach ISS for a capture berthing.
Dragon Arrives at ISS
ISS crew successfully captured the SpaceX Dragon C2+ spacecraft on May 25, 2012, after a slight delay due to a LIDAR issue. The 5-7 tonne spacecraft (SpaceX has not revealed its mass) was susequently berthed to the station.
It is the first visit by a commercial spacecraft to the International Space Station.
At this point in the flight, Dragon had begun to
demonstrate objectives originally intended for a standalone "C3" mission.
SpaceX's Dragon C2+ successfully ended its mission on
May 31, 2012 when the capsule spacecraft splashed down beneath three parachutes in the
Pacific Ocean off the coast of Baja California at 15:42 UTC. Dragon had departed
the International Space Station about 7.5 hours earlier, at 08:07 UTC. The cargo
spacecraft carried more than 600 kg of "down" cargo, including experiments and
old equipment. The reentry and splashdown ended Dragon's COTS 2+ demonstration
mission for NASA, opening the way for more cargo flights.
SpaceX launched its fourth Falcon 9 rocket on October 8, 2012, this time carrying the first operational Dragon spacecraft on NASA's CRS-1 resupply mission to the International Space Station. Liftoff from Cape Canaveral SLC 40 occurred at 00:35 UTC. The second stage inserted Dragon into a 197 x 328 km x 51.65 deg orbit about 9 minutes 49 seconds later. Dragon CRS-1 then seperated and deployed its solar arrays.
During the ascent, a flare was observed in the first stage plume about 79 seconds after liftoff, approximately coinciding with the period of maximum dynamic pressure on the vehicle (or "Max-Q"). The first stage burned about 12-13 seconds longer than expected, and the second stage burned 15-16 seconds longer than planned. SpaceX subsequently stated that an "anomaly" had occurred on one of the rocket's nine first stage Merlin 1C engines, causing it to shut down. The on board guidance system compensated for the loss of thrust by commanding longer burns and a modified flight profile.
Falcon's second stage was expected to perform a second burn after Dragon separation, to insert a 165 kg Orbcomm prototype satellite into a 350 x 750 km orbit. Short of sufficient propellant, and unable to perform any burn with the remaining propellant due to ISS safety constraints, Falcon deployed Orbcomm into a 203 x 323 km x 51.65 deg orbit from which it fell into a destructive reentry into the earth's atmosphere on Ocbober 10, a total loss for Orbcomm..
Despite the successful Dragon insertion, the improper Orbcomm orbit result requires Space Launch Report, given its uncompromising success/fail methodology, to now classify the launch as a failure.
It was the second Falcon 9/Dragon launch of 2012.
SpaceX Dragon Arrives at Station (Updated 10/12/12)
SpaceX successfully delivered Dragon C3 (CRS-1), NASA's first operational commercial cargo mission, to the International Space Station on October 10, 2012. ISS Expedition 33 crew members Akihiko Hoshide and Sunita Williams used the station's robotic arm to grapple and berth Dragon to the station's Harmony module at 11:56 UTC and 1303 UTC, respectively.
Dragon is expected to stay at ISS for 18 days while 400 kg of cargo is unloaded and 759 kg of downmass, including used station hardware and scientific samples, is loaded. Dragon will carry the down cargo to a planned October 28 parachute landing on the Pacific Ocean off the coast of southern California.
SpaceX CRS-1 is the first of 12 Commercial Resupply Services missions contracted for NASA. The program has a $1.6 billion budget.
The Dragon CRS-1 success came despite the challenging failure of one of its nine Falcon 9 first stage engines 79 seconds after liftoff. The lost engine caused Falcon 9's first and second stages to burn longer, forcing the second stage to consume slightly more propellant than planned to boost Dragon into its planned insertion orbit. The first stage burned 12-13 seconds longer, and the second stage 15-16 seconds longer, than the planned 180 seconds and 359 seconds, respectively.
The Falcon 9 second stage was slated to perform a second burn after Dragon separation to insert a 165 kg Orbcomm prototype satellite into a 350 x 750 km orbit. Although the second stage retained enough propellant to very likely achieve the planned orbit, NASA had required prior to the mission that any second stage restart could only occur if there was a better than 99% probability of completing the burn. This was to ensure that the stage and its payload were safely lifted above the ISS orbit. After the extended first burn, the second stage only retained enough propellant to achieve a roughly 95% probability of completing the second burn, so Falcon 9 did not attempt a restart. Orbcomm had to be released into the initial 203 x 323 km x 51.65 deg orbit, from which it soon, on October 10, fell back to a destructive reentery into the earth's atmosphere.
The last time a U.S. rocket lost a first stage engine during ascent but still made it to orbit was the SA-6 flight of May 28, 1964. SA-6 survived an unexpected S-1 outboard engine (No. 8) shutdown 116 seconds after liftoff. The remaining H-1 engines burned about two seconds longer to compensate, with the inboards shutting down at T+142 seconds and the outboards at T+148 seconds. The S-IV stage compensated for the early shutdown to enter a 124 x 140 mile x 31.5 degree orbit, close to the planned 110 x 140 mile orbit. Subsequent Saturn V and Space Shuttle launches also overcame early engine shutdowns to reach orbit, but in those cases the engines were second stage (Apollo 13) or Shuttle SSME "sustainer stage" engines.
SpaceX and NASA completed an investigation of the engine
failure before the next Dragon flight. The final report was not released to the
public. SpaceX cited export control laws as a reason for keeping the results secret.
Company officials summarized what they said were the report's conclusions. They said
that a "material flaw" in the Merlin 1C engine "jacket" had been
determined to be the cause of the failure. The flaw caused a breach that rapidly
depressurized the combusion chamber (an explosive event according to most definitions).
The engine controller detected the depressurization and shut down the engine.
Unless the failure investigation report becomes public, it will not be possible to
confirm company official's statements.
Flight Five: Dragon Propulsion Anomaly Resolved After Successful Falcon 9 Launch (Updated 3/26/13)
The fifth SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket orbited a Dragon spacecraft on NASA's CRS-2 International Space Station resupply mission on March 1, 2013, but Dragon suffered a problem shortly after reaching orbit. The initally unannounced problem occurred around the time that Dragon's solar arrays should have deployed, a process that occurs within minutes of spacecraft separation from the Falcon 9 second stage.
Falcon 9 lifted off from Cape Canaveral Space Launch Complex 40 at 15:10 UTC and provided an uneventful nine minute, two-stage ascent to orbit. Dragon, filled with 847.8 kg of ISS supplies and 201.8 kg of packing materials, separated into a 199 x 323 km x 51.66 deg orbit, and was visible moving away from the second stage in an initially stable fashion.
Shortly after launch, SpaceX head Elon Musk tweeted that three of Dragon's four thruster pods had been inhibited from initiallizing. Crews were working to command an override of those inhibits. Solar array deployment was delayed until at least two thruster pods were brought on line. Each pod contains four or five hypergolic Draco thrusters, for a total of 18 thrusters.
After one orbit, Dragon was still in free drift with
only Thruster Pod 2 working. A problem had occurred that prevented helium
pressurization of the hypergolic thruster oxidizer tanks in the affected thruster pods,
but by 16:40 Mr. Musk was reporting that "Thruster Pod 3 tank pressure trending
positive" and that the team was "preparing to deploy solar arrays."
The arrays deployed shortly after that announcement.
Dragon Drifts from Falcon's Second Stage After Separation. The Trunk and Stowed Solar Arrays are Visible
At 19:59 UTC, nearly 4.5 hours after liftoff, Musk tweeted: "Pods 1 and 4 now online and thrusters engaged. Dragon transitioned from free drift to active control." Dragon subsequently performed a series of orbit raising burns, beginning with a brief five-second test burn at 21:37 UTC and a nearly 36 second long perigee-raising burn at 22:05 UTC.
Dragon's helium pressurization problems occurred after main isolation valves were opened to release high pressure helium system. The helium passes through regulators that drop its pressure to a level that can be safely fed into the hypergolic propellant tanks of the pressure-fed Dragon reaction control system. Check valves ensure that helium flows only into the tanks and that no propellant or helium flows back out.
An obstruction, or obstructions, appeared somewhere in
the helium feed system. Elon Musk stated that one possibility was at the check
valves, but that other possibilities existed. Ice formation due to moisture in the
system is one possible explanation, for example. After waiting for ground station
passes to allow for command uplinks - satellite links were impossible due to Dragon's
drifting - SpaceX engineers cycled the helium isolation valves to "hammer" the
system with slugs of pressure, a process that eventually cleared the lines and allowed the
tanks to be pressurized.
CRS-2 Arrives at ISS
The issues delayed Dragon's planned orbit raising burns, which in turn delayed its planned March 2 ISS rendezvous. On March 2, NASA announced that after a safety review it had approved a March 3 attempt.
CRS-2 Dragon rendezvoused with and berthed to ISS on
March 3, 2013. The station's Canadarm 2, controled by astronaut Kevin Ford, captured
Dragon at 10:31 UTC. Ground controlers in Houston directed the arm to berth Dragon
to the station's Harmony module, a process completed at 13:56 UTC.
Dragon stayed at ISS until March 26. Astronauts off-loaded cargo and then reloaded the capsule with 1,210.9 kg of materials and 159.7 kg of packaging to be returned to Earth. The CRS-2 Dragon reentered a few hours after unberthing from ISS and splashed down in the Pacific Ocean off the coast of Baja, California.
Prior to the launch, the CRS-2 Falcon 9, which
reportedly will be the final Falcon v1.0 variant to fly, performed a two-second long
static test fire on the pad, on February 25, 2013.
Date Vehicle No. Payload Mass Site Orbit ------------------------------------------------------------------------ 06/04/10 Falcon 9 F9-1 Dragon Qual Unit ~5.5 CC 40 LEO  12/08/10 Falcon 9 F9-2 C1/Dragon 1 ~5.5 CC 40 LEO  05/22/12 Falcon 9 F9-3 C2+/Dragon 2 ~6.02 CC 40 LEO/ISS 10/08/12 Falcon 9 F9-4 CRS-1/Dragon 3 ~6.4 CC 40 [LEO/ISS] 03/01/13 Falcon 9 F9-5 CRS-2/Dragon 4 ~6.54 CC 40 LEO/ISS ------------------------------------------------------------------------  1st Falcon 9 launch. Stg 2 rolled during last 3 min of burn.  First COTS test. 288x301kmx34.53deg orbit. Two-orbit mission with Dragon reentry and recovery. Stage 2 restarted, 288 x 11,083km x 34.5deg orbit.  Suffered Merlin 1C Engine No. 1 first stage failure/shutdown at T+79 seconds. First and second stages burned longer to compensate. Dragon CRS-1 deployed into planned orbit, but second stage had insufficient propellant to restart, forcing Orbcomm secondary payload to be deployed into a 203 x 323 km x 51.65 deg orbit, short of planned 350 x 750 km orbit. Launch vehicle failure. Orbcomm reentered on October 10, two days later. ------------------------------------------------------------------------- References
Falcon 9 Data Sheet, SpaceX, 2008